Trump Administration Frames US Decline as Internal Threat, Echoing Fascist Rhetoric
WASHINGTON – The second administration of President Donald Trump is increasingly framing the United States’ position in the world not as one of external challenges, but as a crisis stemming from within, a narrative experts say echoes the core tenets of fascist ideology. This shift, detailed in recent speeches and policy documents, signals a departure from traditional US foreign policy and raises concerns about the administration’s direction.
The rhetoric centers on a perceived “humiliation” of American values and a sense of “civilizational erasure,” as articulated by Secretary of State Marco Rubio at the Munich Security Conference in February. This isn’t simply a discussion of relative decline in power, but a moral failing within society, a theme repeatedly emphasized by Vice President J.D. Vance.
“The threat from within” – a phrase Vance used at the 2025 Munich Security Conference – is not attributed to geopolitical rivals like Russia or China, but to forces eroding the nation’s core identity. Vance specifically pointed to what he described as a retreat from fundamental values in Europe, citing concerns over immigration and cultural shifts. Rubio echoed this sentiment, speaking of a Western civilization “shackled by guilt and shame” and losing its pride.
This narrative is reflected in the 2025 National Security Strategy, which calls for a “restoration and reinvigoration of American spiritual and cultural health” and emphasizes “strong, traditional families.” The strategy, and the administration’s broader messaging, suggests a focus on internal purification and a rejection of multiculturalism.
Political scientists note this framing aligns with populist and, increasingly, fascist tropes. Populist leaders often portray past societies nostalgically, contrasting them with a present state of crisis, while fascism specifically identifies internal enemies responsible for national decay. Philosopher Michael Sandel describes this as a “politics of humiliation,” fueled by a failure to achieve the American Dream and resentment towards perceived winners and losers.
The administration’s rhetoric extends beyond cultural concerns. President Trump, in a September 2025 address to top military generals, called for their deployment to the US homeland, asserting the nation was under attack from “radical left Democrats” and facing an “invasion from within.” He likened these internal forces to a “foreign enemy, but more difficult in many ways.”
Experts warn this language legitimizes violence against perceived enemies within the country. The focus on internal groups, coupled with a difficulty in addressing decline, is a hallmark of fascist ideology, which seeks to cleanse the nation of perceived contaminants.
While the Trump administration initially displayed elements of populism, analysts like Nitasha Kaul and Barry Buzan argue it is moving beyond simple appeals to loyalty and towards a more dangerous territory. They point to the increasing emphasis on internal enemies and a decline that cannot be easily overcome.
The Heritage Foundation’s “Mandate for Leadership” report, while not directly linked to the administration, reinforces this theme, stating that “the greatest threat to America would come not from without, but from within.”
This shift in focus, away from traditional foreign policy concerns and towards an internal struggle for national identity, represents a significant departure for the United States and raises profound questions about its future role in the world. The administration’s rhetoric, steeped in narratives of humiliation and internal threat, warrants close scrutiny as it potentially signals a dangerous turn towards authoritarianism.
References:
Adler-Nissen, Rebecca, and Zarakol, Ayşe. 2021. “Struggles for recognition: The liberal international order and the merger of its discontents.” International Organization 75 (2): 611-634.
Art, David. 2022. “The myth of global populism.” Perspectives on Politics, 20( 3): 999-1011.
Goddard, Stacie. E. 2025. “The Rise and Fall of Great-Power Competition: Trump’s New Spheres of Influence.” Foreign Affairs 104 (8): 8-23.
Griffin, Roger. 1991. The nature of fascism. St. Martin’s Press.
Homolar, Alexandra, and Georg Löfflmann. 2021. “Populism and the Affective Politics of Humiliation Narratives.” Global Studies Quarterly 1 (1): 1-11.
Homolar, Alexandra, and Ronny Scholz. 2019. “The Power of Trump-Speak: Populist Crisis Narratives and Ontological Security.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 32 (3): 344–64.
Joffe, Josef. 2009. The default power: The false prophecy of America’s decline. Foreign Affairs 88 (5): 21-35.
Jokic, Dallas. 2025. “Césaire and Fanon on fascism: The ‘boomerang effect’ beyond the metropole.” Constellations, 32 (4): 601-611.
Kagan, Robert. 2016. “This is how Fascism comes to America”. Washington Post, May 18.
Kaul, Nitasha, and Barry Buzan. 2026. Trump’s new America and the question of fascism. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations.
Parmar, Inderjeet. 2018. “The US-led liberal order: imperialism by another name?.” International Affairs 94 (1): 151-172.
Rubio, Marco. 2025. The nomination of no. Marco Rubio to be U.S. Secretary of State.
Rubio, Marco. 2026. Secretary of State Marco Rubio at the Munich Security Conference.
Roberts, Kevin. 2023. “Foreword: A promise to America.” In: Mandate for leadership: the conservative promise, edited by Paul Dans and Steven Groves. The Heritage Foundation.
Sandel, Michael J. 2020. The tyranny of merit: What’s become of the common good?. Penguin UK.
Specter Matthew, Venkatasubramanian Venkat. 2023. “’America First’: Nationalism, Nativism, and the Fascism Question, 1880–2020.” In: Fascism in America: Past and Present, edited by Gavriel D. Rosenfeld and Janet Ward. Cambridge University Press.
Stanley, Jason. 2018. How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them. Random House.
Trump, Donald, J. 2015. Crippled America: How to make America great again. Simon & Schuster.
Trump, Donald. J. 2025. Remarks to the Department of Defense in Quantico, Virginia.
Trump, Donald. J. 2026. “First Thing: Trump says ‘likely more’ deaths of US troops before Iran” The Guardian, March 2.
Vance, J.D. 2025. Munich Security Conference 2025: Speech by JD Vance and Selected Reactions, Vol. 2.
Wojczewski, Thorsten. 2025. Fascism and foreign policy: Trumpism and the politics of national decline and rebirth. Global Studies Quarterly.
The White House. 2025. National Security Strategy.
